Pancake Style vs. Avenger Style Leather Holsters.
- Angry Dick Leather
- Feb 21
- 3 min read
Updated: Mar 3
When it comes to carrying a sidearm, selecting the right holster is paramount. It's not just about holding your firearm; it's about comfort, concealment, security, and accessibility. Among the vast array of holster styles, two stand out as enduring classics: the Roy Baker Pancake Style holster and the Askins Avenger Scabbard Style Holster. While both are made of leather and designed for outside-the-waistband (OWB) carry, their construction and intended use differ significantly. Let's delve into the differences between Pancake style and Avenger style Leather Holsters.
The Roy Baker Pancake: Hugging Comfort and Discreet Carry.
The "Pancake" holster, popularized by Roy Baker, derives its name from its flat, two-piece construction that sandwiches the firearm between two layers of leather. Here's what defines this design:
Construction: Characterized by two pieces of leather stitched together around the firearm, creating a flat profile. This design maximizes surface contact with the body, distributing the gun's weight evenly.
Belt Slots: Typically features two belt slots, positioned fore and aft of the gun. This design spreads the weight and pulls the gun tightly against the body, enhancing concealment.
Cant: Often offers a slight forward cant, which aids in drawing the weapon while sitting or driving. This cant also helps to break up the gun's outline under clothing.
Retention: Relies primarily on friction and the close fit of the leather to retain the firearm. Some models incorporate a thumb break or tension screw for added security.
Concealment: Excellent for concealment, especially with larger firearms, due to its ability to distribute weight and hug the body closely.
Comfort: Generally comfortable for all-day wear, especially when made from high-quality leather.
The Askins Avenger Scabbard: Speed and Accessibility Above All Else.
The Askins Avenger, favored by legendary lawman Charles Askins, prioritizes speed and ease of draw. Its design is more streamlined and focused on quick access:
Construction: Typically constructed from a single piece of leather, folded around the firearm. This design results in a more rigid and open top.
Belt Slots: Usually features two belt slots, 1 wide belt loop or slot located behind the firearm and 1 tunnel slot behind the firearm. This design pulls the butt of the gun inward towards the wearers body.
Cant: Can feature a forward cant or straight drop.
Retention: Relies primarily on the molded shape of the leather to grip the firearm. Some models may include a tension screw for adjustable retention.
Concealment: Good concealment, but generally not as discreet as a Pancake holster, especially with larger firearms.
Comfort: Comfortable for many, but the closer belt loops can concentrate the weight of the firearm, potentially causing discomfort over extended periods, especially with heavier guns.
Key Differences Summarized:
Feature | Roy Baker Pancake Style Holster | Askins Avenger Style Holster |
Construction | 2 Piece, stitched together. | 1 Piece, folded over gun |
Belt Slots | 2, one on either side of gun. | 2, one behind gun and one to the rear. |
Cant | Moderate to Pronounced forward | Straight Drop or Forward Cant |
Retention | Friction & close fit | Friction and Molding |
Concealment | Excellent | Good |
Comfort | Excellent | Good |
Primary Focus | Concealment & comfort | Speed & accessibility |
Choosing the Right Holster for You:
The best holster for you depends on your individual needs and preferences. Consider the following:
Firearm Size: Pancake holsters are generally better suited for larger firearms that require maximum concealment.
Carry Position: Both designs are typically worn at the 3 or 4 o'clock position (for right-handed shooters).
Draw Speed: If a lightning-fast draw and ease of access is your top priority, the Avenger's design might be preferred.
Body Type: Consider how each holster style will conform to your body shape and clothing.
Activity Level: If you're actively shooting at the range or hunting in the field, the Avenger Holster might be best suited for you. But if you are carrying all day for self defense and concealment, the Pancake Holster might be a better choice.
Conclusion:
Both the Roy Baker Style Pancake holster and the Askins Avenger are time-tested designs that offer unique advantages. The Pancake excels at concealment and comfort, thanks to its flat profile and two-piece construction. The Avenger, on the other hand, prioritizes speed and accessibility with its single-piece molded design. By understanding the nuances of each style, you can make an informed decision and choose the leather holster that best suits your needs and carrying style. Remember to always prioritize safety and practice regularly with your chosen holster to develop a smooth and efficient draw stroke.
Comments